ROBERT CREIGHTON most recently won the 2026 Artie Award for Outstanding Leading Actor in a Play for his starring role in Martin McDonagh’s A Skull in Connemara at Buffalo’s Irish Classical Theatre Company. In 2025, he returned to the role of Timon in Disney’s national tour of The Lion King, a role he played on Broadway in 2010 and 2022. Also for Disney on Broadway, he originated the role of the Duke of Weselton in Frozen. Other Broadway credits include The Mystery of Edwin Drood (Durdles), Anything Goes (Purser/Moonface), Chicago (Amos), The Little Mermaid (Chef Louis), Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, and Jackie Mason’s Laughing Room Only.

He co-wrote and starred in the hit Off-Broadway musical Cagney, which ran for more than 500 performances in 2016–17 and earned him the Fred Astaire Award for Outstanding Male Dancer, along with Drama Desk and Outer Critics Circle Award nominations for Best Lead Actor in a Musical. Following a record-breaking run at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor, NY, Cagney is headed to London in 2027.

Other New York highlights include Angelo in The Comedy of Errors for The Public Theater’s Shakespeare in the Park, starring roles in several New York City Center Encores! productions, and two seasons at Lincoln Center with New York City Opera as Njegus in The Merry Widow and Ko-Ko in The Mikado.

On television, he was a recurring guest star as Clarence Kolb on CBS’s The Good Fight, with other guest roles on Elementary (CBS), Law & Order (NBC), The Family (ABC), and Life on Mars (ABC).

His cabaret Ain’t We Got Fun! won NYC’s prestigious Bistro Award for Outstanding Entertainer, and his debut album of the same name was released on LML Music in 2012.

MY STORY

A Hockey Goalie Who Wanted to Dance

For as long as I can remember, I pictured myself in goal for the Toronto Maple Leafs. In rural Walkerton, Ontario, Canada, where I grew up, the youngest of six kids and the son of a local doctor and nurse, this wasn't an unusual aspiration. 

What was perhaps more surprising was that, right alongside the hockey dream, another grew: I wanted to dance like Fred Astaire and act on Broadway, whatever that meant to a small-town kid. The Toronto Maple Leafs and sports of many kinds are still a big part of my life, but let's just say the NHL was a long shot. Broadway, it turned out, was not.

Music came first. For seven years I sang with the St. Michael's Boys Choir, and at nine I toured England with them, singing in places like Windsor Castle and Southwark Cathedral. That gave me a musical foundation I kept building on through dozens of competitive music festivals in voice, piano, and trumpet.

The acting bug took hold for good in tenth grade, when I auditioned for a community theatre production of Oliver! with the Grey-Wellington Theatre Guild in nearby Harriston. I was sure I'd be playing Oliver, but the wise British director cast me as the Artful Dodger instead. I was disappointed for about a minute, and happily, it's been character roles ever since.

Learning the Steps

At fifteen, I left home for boarding school at Grenville Christian College, where I starred in the school's renowned Gilbert & Sullivan productions each year. 

The summer before my senior year, I attended the Banff Centre School of Fine Arts in the Canadian Rockies. It was a pivotal summer. I performed alongside some of Canada's finest musical theatre talent (all of them older than me), and that's where I was introduced to tap dancing. I learned only a handful of steps that summer, but I practiced them over and over, often into the wee hours, until I could do them fast and furiously. The refinement came later. The passion was settled right there, and it became a lifelong love affair.

After high school, I was itching to get to Toronto or New York, but people I respected convinced me that if I wanted to be in show business for the long haul, I needed solid training first. So I earned a BA in Vocal Performance from Wilfrid Laurier University, with a minor in English. Those years of classical study were invaluable, even as New York kept pulling at me.

During my freshman year, I did my first play at a local semi-professional theatre, in one of my all-time favorite roles: Eugene Morris Jerome in Brighton Beach Memoirs. The summer after my freshman year, I played the Artful Dodger again (not the last time, either!) at Rainbow Stage, Canada’s largest and longest-running outdoor theatre in Winnipeg. A Canadian institution to this day, this is where I earned my Equity card and began my professional career. The production was directed by Alan Lund, one of Canada's foremost musical theatre directors and the man behind the original Anne of Green Gables in Charlottetown. I'd work for him several more times over the next few years, which was incredible on-the-job training. 

Summer stock filled every break between school years, and university life filled in the rest: singing with my doo-wop group, the WeeBops; doing stand-up as my alter ego, Ernest Finkelstein; performing with the local Gilbert & Sullivan Society; and playing in a brass quintet. It was all great training, and all while longing to get to NYC.

After graduation, I spent four months as a liaison officer (recruiter) for Laurier, did a summer stock production at Huron Country Playhouse, then finally headed to New York City to begin my studies at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts (AADA).

New York, New York

The next three years at AADA brought tremendous growth, not only in the classes and on the stages of that wonderful institution, but also by soaking in all the energy and creative spirit of the city. I saw every kind of theatre, opera, dance, music, museums, and more. During summer break, I went home to Ontario to perform in the inaugural and second seasons of the Drayton Festival Theatre, reuniting with Alan Lund.

After the first year at AADA, the program requires an invitation to continue. My first-year class had more than two hundred students. The second year had sixty-four, with whom I graduated. The ultimate cherry on top of the AADA journey was then being invited to join The Graduate Company - a selective ensemble of just eighteen actors. This opportunity allowed us to collaborate with professional outside directors and showcase our talent directly to agents and casting directors.

As a result, I signed with my first agent – Fifi Oscard & Associates – right out of school. A few months later, I made my professional debut in S.N. Behrman's End of Summer with the Phoenix Theatre Company, directed by Kent Paul.

That began a decade of wonderful work in New York and regionally. At Paper Mill Playhouse, I played Peter Pan in Peter Pan, the Artful Dodger (again!) in Oliver!, Eddie Ryan in Funny Girl, and Nicely-Nicely Johnson in Guys and Dolls. I played Og in Finian's Rainbow at Goodspeed and Tobias in Sweeney Todd at St. Louis Rep and Cincinnati Playhouse. I spent two seasons with New York City Opera at Lincoln Center, playing Ko-Ko in The Mikado and Njegus in The Merry Widow, which was broadcast on PBS’s Live from Lincoln Center. I also played Goody King in the original North American tour of Fame, and I was part of the original company of Disney’s The Lion King in Toronto and then Los Angeles.

A Dream Come True: A Broadway Debut

In 2003, I landed my first Broadway show, Laughing Room Only, conceived by and starring the comedian Jackie Mason. We played a few months in Nyack, New York, then moved to Broadway that fall, where we previewed for four weeks and closed abruptly two weeks after opening night. Short as it was, a dream was fulfilled: I finally made it to the Great White Way.

More Broadway followed: Chitty Chitty Bang Bang; The Little Mermaid (Chef Louis); Chicago (Amos); Tony-winning revival of Anything Goes (Purser/Moonface); The Mystery of Edwin Drood (Durdles). Then the wonderful privilege of originating The Duke of Weselton in Disney's Frozen.

And then there's Timon. The Lion King has been part of my life since those original Toronto and Los Angeles companies. I played Timon on Broadway in 2010 and again in 2022, and in 2025 joyfully revisited the role on the road with Disney's national tour.

Other New York highlights include leading roles in New York City Center's Encores! series (Damn Yankees, Little Me, and Paint Your Wagon) and Angelo in The Comedy of Errors for The Public Theater's Shakespeare in the Park. Along the way, I've taken part in countless readings and workshops of new plays and musicals, and have enjoyed performing solo Cabaret shows at some of the wonderful venues in the Big Apple.

A Yankee Doodle Dream

Remember the kid who wanted to dance like Fred Astaire? During my days at AADA, I was spending many hours each week sneaking off to Steps On Broadway or Broadway Dance Center to build on the little tap dancing I had learned as a teenager. One day, one of my teachers, Jack Melanos, suggested I watch some of James Cagney’s films. He said I reminded him of Cagney in my look and energy, and added, “I heard you’ve been tap dancing on the side!” Musical theatre wasn’t a focus at AADA in those days, but wow, he had no idea what he’d started! I began watching Cagney films and reading about the man, and a passion grew - a connection grew. Over time, the dream of creating and starring in a show about this magnetic Hollywood legend took hold. At first on my own, then thankfully with talented collaborators, the musical Cagney became a reality. 

In 2009, Cagney debuted at Florida Stage in West Palm Beach, where it broke their 40-year box office record and won Florida's Carbonell Award for Best New Work. Subsequent productions followed at the Riverside Theatre (Vero Beach, FL) and Drayton Entertainment (Ontario). I had to put it on a shelf while, thankfully, a string of Broadway shows came into my life. In the spring of 2015, The York Theatre Company gave us our New York debut, and we broke another box office record there!

My dream was to bring it to a commercial run in New York City. On April 3, 2016, with the help of many, most notably Producer Riki Kane Larimer, that dream came true. Cagney opened at the Westside Theatre, setting a record for advance ticket sales. Cagney ran for 502 performances.

Playing James Cagney off-Broadway earned me the Fred Astaire Award for Outstanding Male Dancer, an award in the name of the man I'd dreamed of dancing like as a young boy in Walkerton. I was also nominated for Drama Desk and Outer Critics Circle Awards for Best Lead Actor in a Musical, and to be counted among the nominees by the theatre community I loved was a humbling and unforgettable honor.

Since then, Cagney has drawn rave reviews at the El Portal Theatre in Los Angeles and at Pioneer Theatre Company in Salt Lake City. In 2021, we held a full workshop across the pond in London, directed by John Rando with choreography by Joshua Bergasse. This past summer brought a record-breaking run at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor, NY. Now, produced by Riki Kane Larimer and Kate Edelman Johnson, Cagney is headed to The Emerald Theatre in London beginning July 2027.

Albums and Voiceovers and TV, Oh My!

My album Ain’t We Got Fun! was released on LML Music in 2012 and is available wherever you listen to music. My cabaret of the same name, performed at 54 Below, won a New York City Bistro Award for Outstanding Entertainer. I've also performed in concert across the country, including the EPCOT International Festival of the Arts.

My voice turns up in a lot of places. If you’re a gamer, listen for helicopter pilot Rooster McGaw in Grand Theft Auto V and GTA Online. I've recorded spots for AT&T, Verizon, Splenda, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, Buffalo Wild Wings, Nickelodeon, and many others. On film, you can hear my singing voice as part of Disney's animated musical short Frozen Fever and among the rowdy thugs in Tangled. I also lent my voice to the live-action Beauty and the Beast and played sidekick to John Turturro's Rat King in The Nutcracker in 3D. My Audible narration credits include Tommy Spaulding's The Gift of Influence and Boaz Gilad’s The Zenith Code, as well as roles in the thriller Q&A and the series Space 1969.

On television, I've had a recurring role as Clarence Kolb on The Good Fight (CBS), along with guest-starring appearances on Law & Order (NBC), Life on Mars (ABC), Elementary (CBS), and The Family (ABC).

Today

These days you’ll find me at both ends of the Empire State, splitting my time between New York City and Buffalo. Along with performing, I love passing on what I’ve learned over 30+ years in the business. I coach actors, singers, and dancers one-on-one, both virtually and in person in Western New York, on everything from audition songs and monologues to self-tapes, voiceovers, and tap. I also teach masterclasses for schools and colleges, and speak to groups about life on Broadway, sharing all that I’ve learned and all that’s inspired me to keep going!

Most recently, I was honored to receive the 2026 Artie Award for Outstanding Leading Actor in a Play for my starring role in Martin McDonagh’s A Skull in Connemara at Buffalo’s Irish Classical Theatre Company.

The dream that started in Walkerton still lights me up, so I’ll keep doing what I love. But if the Leafs call, I’ll be ready.